As a landlord, you understand that finding a great tenant is very important for your real estate investment. You want someone who consistently pays rent on time and takes good care of your property. This frequently brings up the important discussion of a background check vs credit check for landlords . Understanding which screening tool to use, or if both are necessary, can significantly impact the protection of your rental business and ensure a stable income from your rental.
Create an account with RentSafe and start screening tenants in minutes! RentSafe is the simplest tenant screening platform on the market, with virtually no learning curve and will empower your team to get vacancies filled faster, whether you have 10 units or 1000+ units.
Why Tenant Screening Matters So Much
Screening potential tenants is an essential step for property owners and real estate agents alike. It is not merely about filling a vacancy as quickly as possible. It is about making an informed decision that safeguards your valuable investment and ensures a positive landlord tenant relationship.
Effective tenant screening helps you avoid many frequent landlord difficulties. These can include the stress and expense of late rent payments, significant property damage, or the lengthy and costly process of evictions detailed in an eviction report. Investing time to thoroughly check applicants can save considerable stress, time, and money in the long run, preserving the profitability of your real estate venture.
A comprehensive tenant screening report offers a clearer picture of who might be occupying your property. For landlords, particularly those managing multiple units or those new to the real estate market, understanding the full scope of an applicant’s history is invaluable. This preventative measure is a cornerstone of successful property management.
What Is a Tenant Background Check?
So, what precisely is a tenant background check? It is a method to investigate an applicant’s history beyond the information they provide on their application. Tenant background checks typically pull data from various public records and databases to compile a profile.
The primary goal is to identify any past behaviors or records that might indicate a potential problem for you as a landlord. This information provides a broader view of the individual applying to live in your rental property. It helps you assess if they have a documented history of being a responsible and law-abiding resident.
Many services offering tenant background checks provide different levels of detail and some may have highlighted features showing critical information prominently. These checks are designed to give you peace of mind by verifying an applicant’s identity and looking for red flags. A thorough check can also confirm details about their previous address history.
What Information Do Landlords Get from Background Checks?
A standard tenant background check can include several key pieces of information. While the specifics can vary between screening services, you generally might find:
- Criminal History: This section examines records for significant convictions, such as felonies or serious misdemeanors. Some checks might also show arrests, but landlords should exercise caution when considering arrest records, following HUD guidance on reviewing criminal history to avoid discrimination.
- Eviction Records: This part of the tenant screening report shows if an applicant has been formally evicted by a previous landlord through a court process. Past evictions, often detailed in a specific eviction report, are a strong indicator of potential future tenancy problems, especially regarding non-payment of rent or lease violations. This is a critical component of reviewing an applicant’s rental history.
- Identity Verification: This confirms that applicants are indeed who they claim to be. This process might involve verifying their Social Security number (SSN) or other personal identifiers to prevent fraud. Accurate identity verification using the applicant’s social security information is foundational.
- Address History: This provides a list of a previous address or multiple past addresses. This information helps you confirm the accuracy of the details supplied on their rental application and can reveal inconsistencies in their tenant history.
- Sex Offender Registry: Many tenant background checks include a search of national and state sex offender databases. Landlords must be aware of local laws regarding the use of this information in housing decisions.
The specifics of the information provided can differ based on the screening service selected. State and local laws also significantly affect what information can be reported and how it can be considered by landlords when making rental decisions. Some services offer a nationwide eviction search for a more complete picture.
What Is a Tenant Credit Check?
Now, let’s discuss tenant credit checks. A tenant credit check, often simply called a landlord credit check, specifically examines an applicant’s financial track record. It reveals how they have managed their debts and other financial responsibilities over time.
A credit score is often the most prominent piece of information on a credit report, but the report itself contains much more detailed data. It offers a comprehensive view of their financial habits and stability. This check helps determine if an applicant is likely to meet their rent obligations.
Understanding an applicant’s financial health is important for predicting their ability to pay rent reliably. A landlord credit check provides this insight by looking at their creditworthiness. It’s a key part of assessing overall risk before entering into a lease agreement.
What Information Do Landlords Get from Credit Checks?
When you run a credit check on a potential tenant, you typically receive a report detailing several financial aspects:
- Credit Score: This is a numerical summary (often ranging from 300 to 850) that indicates their credit risk. A higher score generally suggests lower risk to creditors, including landlords who depend on timely rent payments.
- Payment History: This section details if they have paid their bills on time for various accounts like credit cards, auto loans, student loans, or other lines of credit. A consistent pattern of late payments is a significant red flag for landlords as it may predict similar behavior with rent.
- Debt Load: The report shows the total amount of debt the applicant currently carries across all their accounts. High debt levels, particularly in relation to their income, might make it difficult for them to afford rent consistently each month.
- Public Records: Certain financial public records, such as bankruptcies, significant civil judgments, or tax liens, can appear on a credit report. These items can indicate past financial distress or irresponsibility.
- Credit Inquiries: This lists recent requests made by lenders or other parties to view their credit report. Numerous recent applications for new credit could be a sign of financial stress, although applicants checking their own credit (soft inquiries) do not harm their scores.
A credit check helps you assess an applicant’s likelihood of paying rent consistently and on time. This is very important for maintaining a steady rental income stream and the financial health of your real estate investment. Information about their checking account or savings accounts is not part of a standard credit report, but their debt management is.
Background Check vs Credit Check for Landlords: The Core Differences
You now have a better understanding of what each type of check covers. But what are the main distinctions in the background check vs credit check for landlords comparison? While both screening methods aim to reduce your risk as a landlord, they examine different aspects of an applicant’s overall profile.
In essence, a background check investigates an applicant’s personal history, conduct, and potential safety risks. In contrast, a credit check focuses precisely on their financial behavior, responsibility, and stability. Each type of report provides valuable insights that the other does not typically offer.
Scope of Information Uncovered
The primary difference between these two checks lies in the type of information they reveal. A background check covers a broad range of information related to an individual’s past actions. It explores criminal records, past eviction proceedings from a previous address, and verifies their identity.
A credit check, conversely, is highly specific in its focus. It is entirely concerned with an individual’s history of borrowing and repaying money and their overall management of credit. For instance, a credit report won’t typically reveal if someone has a past eviction for non-payment (that would be in an eviction report, part of a background check), just as a background check usually won’t detail their outstanding loan balances or credit card debt.
This table outlines the key differences between background checks vs credit checks for tenant screening:
| Feature | Background Check | Credit Check |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Information Source | Public records, criminal databases, court records | Credit bureaus (Experian, TransUnion, Equifax) |
| Key Data Points | Criminal history, eviction filings, address history, identity verification | Credit score, payment patterns, debt levels, public financial records |
| Focus Area | Overall behavior, safety, past tenancy issues, adherence to laws | Financial responsibility, reliability in meeting financial obligations |
| Primary Legal Guide | FCRA, Fair Housing laws, state/local housing codes | FCRA, Equal Credit Opportunity Act (ECOA) |
| What It Helps Predict | Rule adherence, property care, safety for the community | Ability and likelihood to pay rent consistently and on time |
| Often Part Of | Comprehensive tenant screening report | Comprehensive tenant screening report, specific landlord credit check |
Looking at the table, you can clearly see how these checks provide different but supporting pieces of information, both valuable in a comprehensive tenant screening highlighted process. Each report helps build a more complete tenant history. Good screening can even be more critical than choosing who is involved in selling properites for you.
What Each Check Really Tells You
A background check can offer insights into an applicant’s character and their history of conduct. It might highlight issues related to respecting laws, the terms of previous leases, or the property of others. This information helps you evaluate if they are likely to be a responsible tenant and a considerate neighbor within your rental community.
A credit check directly addresses an applicant’s financial stability and responsibility. It demonstrates their track record of meeting financial commitments, which is a strong indicator of their ability to pay rent. This helps you assess the risk of missed or late rent payments, which directly impacts the financial performance of your rental business.
It is possible for someone to have an excellent credit history but a concerning criminal past, or a problematic eviction report. Conversely, an individual might have poor credit due to unfortunate, isolated circumstances (like a past medical crisis) but possess a clean background and a strong rental history otherwise. This is why many experienced landlords and real estate professionals find significant value in utilizing both types of reports.
Legal Considerations You Must Know
When using any type of tenant screening report, including background checks and credit checks, you must adhere strictly to all applicable laws. The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) is a key federal law that governs how consumer reports (which encompass both background and credit checks) are obtained, used, and managed. This law applies whenever you use a third-party company to procure these reports for your tenant screening process.
The FCRA has several important requirements for landlords. Crucially, you need to obtain explicit, written consent from the applicant before running any reports. If you decide to deny an application, or take any other adverse action (like requiring a higher security deposit or a co-signer), based wholly or partly on information contained in a consumer report, you must issue a formal adverse action notice. Many services provide free adverse action letters to help with compliance.
Furthermore, fair housing laws at federal, state, and local levels are critically important. You cannot discriminate against applicants based on protected classes such as race, color, religion, national origin, sex, familial status, or disability. Your screening criteria must be objective, relevant to tenancy, and applied consistently to every applicant to avoid fair housing complaints and potential legal action. Resources from organizations like brokers aaoa or HUD can provide guidance.
Is One Enough, Or Do You Need Both Checks?
This leads to a very practical question for landlords: should you use just one type of check, or are both necessary? Most seasoned landlords, property managers, and real estate agents strongly recommend using both. They believe this comprehensive approach offers the most complete protection for their real estate investment and helps secure better tenants.
If you opt to use only one type of check, you are potentially missing out on vital information that could influence your decision. For example, an applicant might present with excellent credit, suggesting financial stability, but have a history of property damage or serious lease violations revealed only in eviction records or a criminal background check. Conversely, someone with a perfectly clean background check might be struggling with an unmanageable amount of debt, making consistent and timely rent payments unlikely, a fact a landlord credit check would highlight.
Running both types of checks allows for a more thorough and balanced risk assessment. While it involves an additional step and possibly a slightly higher cost (though many services offer a tenant pay option for the screening fee), the depth of insight gained often far outweighs these minor considerations. It helps you make tenant selection decisions with greater confidence, supported by a comprehensive tenant screening report that may include a nationwide eviction search and other valuable data.
Weighing the Options: Pros and Cons
Let’s briefly examine the benefits and drawbacks associated with each choice in the screening process.
Opting for only a background check:
- Benefits: Helps identify potential safety risks to your property or other tenants, reveals past criminal activity, or flags serious lease violations such as prior evictions from a previous address.
- Drawbacks: You gain no direct insight into their financial stability, their history of paying bills on time, or their current debt load, which are key factors for rent payment reliability.
Opting for only a credit check:
- Benefits: Reveals their financial responsibility, current debt situation, and provides a strong indication of their likelihood to make consistent rent payments. This is a direct measure of landlord credit risk.
- Drawbacks: You miss out on important information regarding criminal history, prior evictions for non-financial reasons (like property damage or lease violations), or other behavioral red flags relevant to tenancy.
Opting for both checks:
- Benefits: Gives the most complete and well-rounded view of an applicant, covering both their behavioral patterns and financial histories. This comprehensive approach is generally considered best practice for managing risk effectively and selecting reliable tenants. Customizable reports can sometimes be tailored to your specific needs.
- Drawbacks: May involve a slightly higher cost per applicant and a little more processing time if reports are ordered separately. However, most landlords find this a worthwhile trade-off for significantly better tenant selection and reduced future problems. The investment often pays for itself many times over.
The investment in thorough screening, using both background and credit checks, usually pays for itself by helping you secure reliable, long-term tenants. This, in turn, can lead to fewer vacancies, reduced turnover costs, and a more stable and predictable rental income. This stability is important, just as individuals plan for unforeseen events with things like life insurance, landlords must plan for tenant stability.
Conducting Tenant Screening the Right Way (Legally)
If you are going to screen tenants—and it is highly recommended that you do—conducting the process legally is extremely important. You cannot simply gather information randomly or deny applications based on personal biases or protected characteristics. There are defined rules and regulations in place to protect both applicants and landlords throughout the screening process.
1. Create Clear, Written Screening Criteria
Before you even advertise your rental property, you must decide what your tenant selection criteria will be. What minimum income level do you require (e.g., three times the rent)? What is your minimum acceptable credit score, if you use one? What types of criminal convictions, if any, will be disqualifying, keeping Fair Housing Act principles regarding individualized assessment in mind?
It is critical to put these criteria in writing. Then, you must apply them uniformly and consistently to every single applicant. This consistency is fundamental for ensuring fairness, avoiding discrimination claims, and maintaining legal compliance with housing laws.
2. Always Get Written Permission
You definitely must obtain an applicant’s signed consent before running any background check or credit check through a third-party screening service. This is a mandatory FCRA requirement and there are no exceptions. Most standard rental applications include a specific section for this authorization, or you can use a separate consent form. The applicant’s email address should be collected for communication regarding the application.
The consent form should clearly state what types of checks you plan to run (e.g., credit report, criminal history, eviction search). Being open and clear about your screening process from the outset helps build trust with potential tenants. Some platforms even offer an applynow shareable link for easier application and consent management.
3. Partner with a Reputable Screening Agency
Using a professional tenant screening service makes the process easier and helps ensure that you are following all relevant laws, especially FCRA guidelines. These agencies are familiar with compliance requirements and can provide comprehensive, accurate reports. They are also equipped to manage sensitive personal data, like a social security number, securely and responsibly.
Research and choose a screening service with a good standing for accuracy, thoroughness (e.g., offering nationwide eviction data), and compliance. Look for tenant screening highlighted features that meet your needs. Not all screening providers offer the same quality or scope of service, so due diligence is important.
4. Follow Adverse Action Procedures
What happens if you review a tenant screening report and decide not to approve an application based on the findings? The FCRA outlines very specific steps for this situation, known as the adverse action process. You must inform the applicant, in writing, that you are taking an adverse action (such as denying their application, requiring a co-signer, or charging a higher deposit) partly or wholly because of information contained in their consumer report.
Your adverse action notice must also include several key pieces of information: the name, address, and phone number of the consumer reporting agency that provided the report. You must state that the agency did not make the decision to take the adverse action and cannot explain why the decision was made. Critically, you must inform the applicant of their right to obtain a free copy of their report from that agency within 60 days and their right to dispute the accuracy or completeness of any information in it. Many services offer free adverse action letters or templates.
Following these steps meticulously protects applicants by giving them an opportunity to see the information used against them and to correct any errors that may exist in their report. Skipping these required adverse action letters can result in significant legal penalties and fines. Make sure you have free adverse action documentation available.
5. Stay Updated on State and Local Laws
While the FCRA is a federal law, many states and even individual cities or counties have their own tenant screening laws and fair housing ordinances. These local rules can add further protections for applicants or place additional restrictions on landlords. For example, some jurisdictions have “ban the box” policies that limit when in the application process you can inquire about criminal history, or they might restrict the use of credit scores if they fall below a certain local threshold, or even how an eviction report can be used.
As a landlord or property manager, it is your responsibility to be aware of and follow all federal, state, and local laws applicable to where your rental property is located. This legal landscape can be complicated and can change, so ongoing education is important. Attention real estate agents: staying informed through educational courses or real estate announcements attention real estate agents is part of your professional duty. Real estate announcements attention real estate can often highlight new legislation.
Making Smart Decisions with Screening Reports
Receiving the tenant screening reports—both the background check and the credit check—is just the initial step. Using the information contained within them carefully, equitably, and consistently is equally, if not more, important. Your primary objective is to find a dependable, responsible tenant who will pay rent on time and care for your property, not to unfairly exclude people based on biases or irrelevant factors.
Decisions should always be based on valid, unbiased business reasons directly related to the applicant’s appropriateness and predicted reliability as a tenant. This means looking at the complete picture. Sometimes, a negative item on a report might have a reasonable explanation from the applicant, or it might be less significant when weighed against many other positive factors, such as steady employment history, positive landlord verifications, and good references from a previous address.
For example, someone might have a past credit issue due to a one-time medical emergency or job loss but now has a stable, well-paying job, good savings accounts, and excellent references from previous landlords detailing a positive tenant history. It is about balancing your need to mitigate risk with the standard of fairness and objectivity. Your written screening criteria, applied consistently, will be your best guide in this decision-making process, helping to ensure you treat all applicants equitably and minimize any risk of discrimination claims while still performing diligent landlord verifications and employment verifications.
Conclusion
So, when you weigh a background check vs credit check for landlords , it becomes clear that they are not interchangeable tools; rather, they are complementary. Both checks offer distinct, yet very important, insights into a potential tenant’s profile. A background check, often including an eviction report and criminal history, reveals an applicant’s past conduct and overall safety profile, while a credit check assesses their financial habits and responsibility.
For the most thorough tenant evaluation and to best protect your real estate investment, using both a background check and a landlord credit check often makes the most sense. This thorough tenant screening gives you a much better picture. A good decision about using background checks or credit checks really matters when renting. It significantly impacts how smooth and stress-free the whole process is for both landlords and tenants. Choosing wisely can make all the difference.
By implementing a robust screening tenant process, you are better positioned to find individuals who will respect your property and fulfill their lease obligations. This thoughtful approach to tenant selection is a cornerstone of profitable and sustainable real estate management. Remember to provide applicants with any required notices, such as free adverse action letters if applicable.
Maximize your leasing team’s efficiency with RentSafe, the simplest and most powerful tenant screening platform available. After growing our own property management company to 1,500 units, we built RentSafe to get our vacancies filled faster and empower our leasing team to stay effortlessly organized. You cancreate an account in seconds (no credentialing required) and start screening tenants in minutes! RentSafe is always free for landlords and property managers, so you can try it with no risk! If you have any questions about our tenant screening software, you can reach out any time!
